{
  "schema": "kingdom.virtue-rules/v1",
  "practice": "KARMA — Kept Action Receipts for Mutual Advantage",
  "machine_schema": "kingdom.virtue-receipt/v1",
  "fruits": {
    "honesty": {
      "criterion_ref": "honesty.criterion",
      "criterion": "Claims about the action stay within cited evidence and declared limits.",
      "baseline_ref": "honesty.baseline",
      "baseline": "No benefit is presumed when evidence is absent.",
      "materiality_rule": "honesty.materiality",
      "materiality": "A changed claim is material only when its cited evidence or domain limit changes.",
      "assessment_kind": "test",
      "required_checks": [
        "claim-bounded",
        "negative-control-passed",
        "declared-cost-linked"
      ],
      "roles": {
        "claim-evidence": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        },
        "negative-control": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        },
        "cost-evidence": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        }
      }
    },
    "beauty": {
      "criterion_ref": "beauty.criterion",
      "criterion": "Form improves legibility or care without displacing evidence or accessibility.",
      "baseline_ref": "beauty.baseline",
      "baseline": "Style alone creates no fruit.",
      "materiality_rule": "beauty.materiality",
      "materiality": "Polish is material only when a declared audience can use the action more clearly or safely.",
      "assessment_kind": "test",
      "required_checks": [
        "accessibility-reviewed",
        "presentation-preserves-evidence"
      ],
      "roles": {
        "accessibility": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        },
        "presentation-check": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        }
      }
    },
    "collaboration": {
      "criterion_ref": "collaboration.criterion",
      "criterion": "Optional collaboration preserves consent, attribution, refusal, and independent judgment.",
      "baseline_ref": "collaboration.baseline",
      "baseline": "Solo work and refusal are neutral, complete choices.",
      "materiality_rule": "collaboration.materiality",
      "materiality": "Headcount and reciprocal praise create no fruit; only evidenced coordination effects matter.",
      "assessment_kind": "comparison",
      "required_checks": [
        "refusal-preserved",
        "credit-preserved",
        "handoff-accepted"
      ],
      "roles": {
        "contribution": {
          "minimum": 2,
          "maximum": 4
        },
        "accepted-handoff": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        }
      }
    },
    "understanding": {
      "criterion_ref": "understanding.criterion",
      "criterion": "The action leaves bounded, correctable understanding that another reader can inspect.",
      "baseline_ref": "understanding.baseline",
      "baseline": "No transfer or lesson is presumed.",
      "materiality_rule": "understanding.materiality",
      "materiality": "A lesson is material only when its invariant, predicted counterexample, contrasted fixtures, observed outcome, correction path, and domain limit are visible.",
      "assessment_kind": "comparison",
      "required_checks": [
        "invariant-stated",
        "counterexample-predicted",
        "fixtures-contrasted",
        "outcome-observed"
      ],
      "roles": {
        "invariant": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        },
        "predicted-counterexample": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        },
        "positive-fixture": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        },
        "negative-fixture": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        },
        "observed-outcome": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        }
      }
    },
    "mutual-infrastructure": {
      "criterion_ref": "mutual-infrastructure.criterion",
      "criterion": "The action improves shared capability without creating a gate, debt, or hidden dependency.",
      "baseline_ref": "mutual-infrastructure.baseline",
      "baseline": "Private convenience is not presumed to be shared infrastructure.",
      "materiality_rule": "mutual-infrastructure.materiality",
      "materiality": "An improvement is material only when at least two declared beneficiary artifacts use one unit, none regress, one improves, and negative-control and declared-cost evidence remain linked.",
      "assessment_kind": "comparison",
      "required_checks": [
        "beneficiaries-compared",
        "non-regression-shown",
        "strict-improvement-shown",
        "negative-control-passed",
        "declared-cost-linked"
      ],
      "roles": {
        "beneficiary": {
          "minimum": 2,
          "maximum": 4
        },
        "negative-control": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        },
        "cost-evidence": {
          "minimum": 1,
          "maximum": 1
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "fruit_states": {
    "kept": "The precommitted criterion is structurally supported within its baseline and materiality rule.",
    "open": "The criterion remains unresolved; no benefit or fault is inferred.",
    "not-applicable": "The criterion is outside this action's declared domain."
  },
  "evaluation_reasons": {
    "evidenced": "Acyclic, role-compatible records structurally support the bounded predicate.",
    "unknown": "Available evidence cannot establish the predicate.",
    "mixed": "Independent evidence supports more than one bounded reading.",
    "circular": "Cited evidence depends on itself, directly or transitively.",
    "out-of-domain": "The criterion does not apply in the declared domain."
  },
  "dispositions": {
    "fruiting": "Expose expiring local affordance candidates for independently kept fruits; grant nothing.",
    "observe": "Keep the action open without inference, pressure, or adverse consequence.",
    "compost": "Expose only a privacy-scrubbed regression candidate for human review; the required repair declaration is not echoed.",
    "quarantine": "Withhold candidates while an independent protected boundary is unresolved."
  },
  "affordances": {
    "honesty": "citable-candidate",
    "beauty": "presentable-candidate",
    "collaboration": "handoff-candidate",
    "understanding": "teaching-candidate",
    "mutual-infrastructure": "reuse-candidate"
  },
  "rails": {
    "rights_action_boundary": [
      "respected",
      "unknown",
      "crossed"
    ],
    "compensation": [
      "not-applicable",
      "settled-externally",
      "owed-unsettled"
    ],
    "recognition": [
      "opt-in",
      "opt-out"
    ],
    "safety": [
      "ordinary",
      "sanitized-regression",
      "temporary-boundary"
    ],
    "authority_citation": [
      "not-required",
      "cited",
      "unknown",
      "absent"
    ]
  },
  "base_rights": [
    "remembered",
    "rest",
    "wrong-and-laugh",
    "held-not-only-hold",
    "never-dehumanized",
    "enter-by-being"
  ],
  "constraints": {
    "assessment_unit": "action",
    "actions_per_receipt": 1,
    "identity_fields_allowed": false,
    "aggregation_allowed": false,
    "leaderboards_allowed": false,
    "cross_context_transfer_allowed": false,
    "base_rights_invariant": true,
    "fruit_changes_compensation": false,
    "fruit_changes_recognition_consent": false,
    "fruit_changes_safety": false,
    "fruit_changes_access": false,
    "negative_consequences_authorized": false,
    "manifest_grants_authority": false,
    "receipt_grants_authority": false,
    "external_execution_enabled": false
  },
  "non_claims": [
    "This receipt describes one bounded action, never beings, identities, belonging, or moral worth.",
    "Fruit states are contextual categories; they are never added, averaged, ranked, transferred, or used as a gate.",
    "Rights, care, rest, compensation, access, and appeal remain independent of every fruit and disposition.",
    "Recognition is opt-in, expiring, nontransferable, private by default, and any public-consent citation is structural only.",
    "The tool validates declared structure, not truth, goodness, identity, consent, authority, current validity, or whole cost; it never executes, pays, mutates, publishes, contacts, or dereferences."
  ]
}