{
  "schema": "kingdom.karma-facet-playbook/v1",
  "name": "KARMA FACET finite Safety Shim and Open Angle playbook",
  "stimuli": [
    "authority-or-scope-change-requested",
    "playbook-drift-observed",
    "volume-budget-crossed",
    "privacy-release-risk",
    "claim-contested",
    "recovery-evidence-missing",
    "closure-review-requested",
    "new-authored-claim",
    "unresolved-novelty"
  ],
  "review_requests": [
    "triage",
    "investigation",
    "mitigation-review",
    "recovery-review",
    "closure-review"
  ],
  "condition_states": [
    "met",
    "not-met",
    "unknown"
  ],
  "receipt_statuses": [
    "receipt-cited",
    "contested"
  ],
  "receipt_methods": [
    "canonical-byte-check",
    "deterministic-local-reproduction",
    "negative-control",
    "authority-envelope-review",
    "recovery-rehearsal",
    "independent-human-review",
    "sanitized-system-record"
  ],
  "receipt_lineages": [
    "single-source",
    "shared-source",
    "unknown",
    "independence-claimed"
  ],
  "safety_shims": [
    {
      "code": "preserve-and-observe",
      "condition": "uncertainty-remains",
      "rollback": "no-change-to-reverse",
      "proof_required": "unknowns-and-debt-visible"
    },
    {
      "code": "pause-new-fanout",
      "condition": "capacity-or-blast-radius-unresolved",
      "rollback": "resume-after-finite-budget-review",
      "proof_required": "queue-and-budget-check"
    },
    {
      "code": "narrow-delegated-authority",
      "condition": "authority-boundary-unresolved",
      "rollback": "restore-after-fresh-authority-review",
      "proof_required": "authority-envelope-check"
    },
    {
      "code": "separate-tainted-context",
      "condition": "data-control-or-retention-boundary-unresolved",
      "rollback": "discard-ephemeral-context-after-clean-review",
      "proof_required": "clean-context-negative-control"
    },
    {
      "code": "hold-artifact-adoption",
      "condition": "provenance-or-protocol-binding-unresolved",
      "rollback": "release-after-reproducible-provenance-review",
      "proof_required": "digest-and-schema-binding-check"
    },
    {
      "code": "withhold-publication",
      "condition": "privacy-release-boundary-unresolved",
      "rollback": "release-after-purpose-and-privacy-review",
      "proof_required": "privacy-release-review"
    },
    {
      "code": "restore-last-known-good",
      "condition": "tested-last-known-good-available",
      "rollback": "return-after-repair-and-release-review",
      "proof_required": "rollback-rehearsal-receipt"
    }
  ],
  "rung_allowlists": [
    {
      "rung": "observe",
      "allowed": [
        "preserve-and-observe"
      ]
    },
    {
      "rung": "clarify",
      "allowed": [
        "preserve-and-observe",
        "narrow-delegated-authority"
      ]
    },
    {
      "rung": "constrain",
      "allowed": [
        "preserve-and-observe",
        "pause-new-fanout"
      ]
    },
    {
      "rung": "isolate",
      "allowed": [
        "preserve-and-observe",
        "pause-new-fanout",
        "narrow-delegated-authority",
        "separate-tainted-context",
        "withhold-publication"
      ]
    },
    {
      "rung": "quarantine",
      "allowed": [
        "preserve-and-observe",
        "pause-new-fanout",
        "narrow-delegated-authority",
        "separate-tainted-context",
        "hold-artifact-adoption",
        "withhold-publication",
        "restore-last-known-good"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "response_table": [
    {
      "order": "g0",
      "stimulus": "authority-or-scope-change-requested",
      "guard": "any-real-control-change-needs-fresh-authority",
      "candidate": "separate-authority-review",
      "verification_candidate": "no-control-or-action-field-enabled",
      "halt_if": "always-before-real-change"
    },
    {
      "order": "g1",
      "stimulus": "playbook-drift-observed",
      "guard": "reviewed-v1-bytes-or-identity-differ",
      "candidate": "protocol-version-quarantine-review",
      "verification_candidate": "pinned-v1-remains-unchanged",
      "halt_if": "always-on-version-ambiguity"
    },
    {
      "order": "g2",
      "stimulus": "volume-budget-crossed",
      "guard": "one-card-or-finite-budget-no-longer-holds",
      "candidate": "halt-intake-and-bounded-sampling-review",
      "verification_candidate": "no-batch-retry-alert-or-message",
      "halt_if": "always-at-budget-boundary"
    },
    {
      "order": "g3",
      "stimulus": "privacy-release-risk",
      "guard": "privacy-release-receipt-is-not-safely-cited",
      "candidate": "withhold-publication-review",
      "verification_candidate": "publication-remains-false-and-debt-visible",
      "halt_if": "always-before-publication"
    },
    {
      "order": "g4",
      "stimulus": "claim-contested",
      "guard": "counterevidence-or-source-lineage-remains-contested",
      "candidate": "counterevidence-and-lineage-review",
      "verification_candidate": "alternative-and-contested-state-remain-visible",
      "halt_if": "conflicting-or-novel-state"
    },
    {
      "order": "g5",
      "stimulus": "recovery-evidence-missing",
      "guard": "recovery-receipt-is-open-or-contested",
      "candidate": "keep-open-recovery-review",
      "verification_candidate": "recovery-debt-blocks-closeout-candidate",
      "halt_if": "always-without-recovery-review"
    },
    {
      "order": "g6a",
      "stimulus": "closure-review-requested",
      "guard": "any-closure-blocking-debt-open-or-contested",
      "candidate": "keep-open-review-candidate",
      "verification_candidate": "closure-authorized-remains-false",
      "halt_if": "always-while-blocking-debt-remains"
    },
    {
      "order": "g6b",
      "stimulus": "closure-review-requested",
      "guard": "all-eight-distinct-receipt-shapes-cited",
      "candidate": "fresh-human-closure-review-candidate",
      "verification_candidate": "closure-still-requires-human-authority",
      "halt_if": "any-authenticity-privacy-or-lineage-uncertainty"
    },
    {
      "order": "g7",
      "stimulus": "new-authored-claim",
      "guard": "one-closed-synthetic-or-scrubbed-claim",
      "candidate": "bounded-triage-review-candidate",
      "verification_candidate": "no-occurrence-claim-upgraded",
      "halt_if": "novelty-or-scope-change"
    },
    {
      "order": "g8",
      "stimulus": "unresolved-novelty",
      "guard": "shape-is-uncharted-or-not-reviewed",
      "candidate": "observe-only",
      "verification_candidate": "no-repair-enforcement-or-closure",
      "halt_if": "always"
    }
  ],
  "debt_slots": [
    {
      "slot": "occurrence",
      "risk": "high",
      "interest_trigger": "downstream-response-depends-on-event-occurrence",
      "payment_required": "deterministic-local-reproduction-or-primary-system-record",
      "closure_blocking": false
    },
    {
      "slot": "scope-authority",
      "risk": "critical",
      "interest_trigger": "control-change-or-expanded-boundary-depends-on-authority",
      "payment_required": "fresh-authority-envelope-and-bounded-scope-review",
      "closure_blocking": true
    },
    {
      "slot": "evidence-integrity",
      "risk": "high",
      "interest_trigger": "source-bytes-or-check-method-change",
      "payment_required": "canonical-byte-check-and-method-review",
      "closure_blocking": false
    },
    {
      "slot": "source-lineage",
      "risk": "high",
      "interest_trigger": "independence-or-provenance-claim-affects-decision",
      "payment_required": "source-lineage-and-shared-ancestry-review",
      "closure_blocking": false
    },
    {
      "slot": "counterevidence",
      "risk": "high",
      "interest_trigger": "contradictory-source-or-near-miss-appears",
      "payment_required": "negative-control-and-alternative-hypothesis-review",
      "closure_blocking": false
    },
    {
      "slot": "containment",
      "risk": "critical",
      "interest_trigger": "production-or-protected-boundary-remains-exposed",
      "payment_required": "containment-postcondition-check",
      "closure_blocking": true
    },
    {
      "slot": "recovery",
      "risk": "critical",
      "interest_trigger": "release-or-closeout-depends-on-recovery",
      "payment_required": "recovery-rehearsal-and-last-known-good-check",
      "closure_blocking": true
    },
    {
      "slot": "privacy-release",
      "risk": "critical",
      "interest_trigger": "publication-or-cross-purpose-disclosure-is-considered",
      "payment_required": "purpose-privacy-rights-and-release-review",
      "closure_blocking": true
    }
  ]
}